Mykonos IllustratedAN INDEPENDENT VIEW OF THE ISLAND
WORLD CLOCK
Mykonos
New York
Washington DC
Los Angeles
Dubai
Monte Carlo
London
Milano
Editorial: Can Plato Be Read on Mykonos? — banner image
Image Part of the Mykonos Illustrated Editorial Collection. ® All Rights Reserved · Editorial illustration, not a documented scene.

Published

Editorial

Can Plato Be Read on Mykonos?

The Japanese Man, the Party and the Symposium

August on Mykonos. The heat is close to scorching everything, and in a small courtyard, beneath a tree, a Japanese man sits alone on a wooden chair reading Plato's Symposium. The image seems almost staged: a citizen of a society often described as the most disciplined in the world, devoted to the collective, finds himself on the island that has become synonymous with excess, studying this great text of ancient thought on love. And yet, the more you observe it, the less out of place it seems.

Japan is a fine contradiction in itself. Geographically it belongs to the Far East, yet intellectually it has been in dialogue with the West for a century and a half. From the era of Emperor Meiji, Japan turned systematically towards Europe. It studied and absorbed Western philosophy without abandoning its own identity. It is a society that knows how to hold ritual together with innovation, tradition with progress, Western freedom with discipline. The man in the courtyard is no stranger to Plato, and quite rightly he has come to read him in his own country. What is particularly interesting, however, is that the reader chooses the place more closely tied to the idea of the party than to philosophy.

And here lies the most interesting connection: the Symposium is, literally, a party. The word means "drinking together with others", and the dialogue unfolds at the symposium held at the home of the poet Agathon in Athens, where the guests praise Eros until Alcibiades bursts in, drunk.

Plato has Socrates say that the greatest goods come to us through madness, when it is a divine gift. The Mykonos of madness and the Plato of wisdom, then, are by no means opponents. They are two sides of the same question: how to live in madness without losing oneself.

Editorial: Has anyone ever asked this guy? — banner image
Image Part of the Mykonos Illustrated Editorial Collection. ® All Rights Reserved

Editorial

Has anyone ever asked this guy?

The fine line between greed and compassion

A lobster on a silver platter is an eloquent image of celebration. It speaks of appetite, of cost, and of the theatre of service. It says very little about the animal. The question in the title interrupts this convention: before we admire the presentation, may we ask about the life of this ill-fated lobster?

The lobster cannot answer us in words. That does not make its experience an empty question. After all, a 2021 review led by researchers at the London School of Economics examined more than 300 scientific studies on cephalopods and decapod crustaceans. It recommended that they be treated as sentient animals and that their welfare be taken seriously.

A beautiful table may distract us from the difficult decisions that preceded it. Yet while we are always quick to ask where a wine comes from, we rarely take the trouble to ask how an animal reached the plate.

The fine line is crossed when pleasure becomes an excuse to stop thinking. Imagine, after all this, how hypocritical it would be of me to add a postscript, for the sake of professional ethics, stating that the lobster in the image is a schematic argument and not evidence of the practices of any particular kitchen.

You choose maps and 3D viewers.

External maps and 3D viewers are optional. They do not load before your choice. The site remains available without them. Cookie policy

Privacy and cookie settings

External maps and 3D viewers are optional. They do not load before your choice. The site remains available without them.

Necessary storage for security, navigation and remembering this choice remains active. We do not install advertising trackers.

Withdrawal immediately removes maps and 3D viewers. Cookies already stored by a third party can be cleared in your browser or the provider’s settings.

Read the cookie policy